What the Supreme Court decision upholding the Affordable Care Act can teach clients about selecting counsel and litigating cases
No matter what your political persuasion or how you feel about the decision, the Supreme Court’s decision today upholding the Affordable Care Act against various constitutional challenges can teach clients some valuable lessons about selecting counsel and litigating cases:
1. Successful Litigation Requires More Than a Silver-Tongued Devil. Based largely on stereotypes driven by the media and popular culture, many people erroneously assume that the best-dressed, best-spoken, best-looking lawyer will always win the case. That simply is not true. In our experience, the most successful lawyers are those that are the most well-rounded. To be sure, the ability to effectively make an oral argument may be important in a given case. But equally, if not more important, is the ability to develop a successful strategy, the ability, willingness and commitment to work hard and put in as many hours as it takes to get to a successful result, and the ability to generate an absolutely top-notch written work product.
2. Experience Counts. To successfully accomplish their legal goals, the client MUST hire a lawyer that has the experience to identify and understand the legal and practical issues involved in a particular legal matter and the experience to then formulate and implement a strategy to successfully address such issues. Such experience is not only or necessarily a function of age alone. On the contrary, such experience can only be gained by having “fought the battles” so to speak. To increase the chances of a successful result, the client must hire an attorney who has successfully litigated multiple cases in the subject matter and court where the client’s particular matter is or will be pending. The client’s legal matter simply is too important to hire a lawyer who will learn and gain experience on the client’s dime – hire a lawyer who already knows what he or she is doing, and has a track record of successful results.
3. It’s Never Over Until It’s Over. The history of the Supreme Court litigation of the challenges to the Affordable Care Act well illustrate the above points and caution the client to understand that a case is never over until the final decision is rendered. For those that followed the case, you will remember that the performance of the Government attorney at oral argument was routinely panned and criticized and the commentators alomsot all opined that the Affordable Care Act would be invalidated. But as they say, the reports of the demise of the ACA were greatly exaggerated. The critics did not realize the work that the Government attorney did behind the scenes and outside the courtroom to guide the case to a successful result. The Government attorney and his team obviously had the experience to formulate a strategy that ultimately was a winning strategy and he and his team had the tenacity and skill to generate a high-quality written work product and successfully implement his strategy. That’s what it takes to win.
Individuals and businesses looking to hire an attorney for a litigation matter should well heed these lessons.
The Supreme Court has upheld the Affordable Care Act against various constitutional and other challenges
In one of the most significant decisions in the last 50 years, the United States Supreme Court today upheld the Affordable Care Act against various constitutional and other challenges. This decision undoubtedly will have far-ranging implications for constitutional jurisprudence (especialy under the Commerce Clause) as well as the current political landscape. The full opinion can be found here: http://www.supremecourt.gov/opinions/11pdf/11-393c3a2.pdf
Welcome to the blog of The Affinity Law Group. Our law firm is a San Diego-based law firm that was founded in June 2003 to provide creative and effective representation to those businesses and individuals looking for affordable legal representation by highly skilled and experienced attorneys. We handle just about any type of litigation, business transaction, intellectual property and immigration matter you can imagine. Please visit our website at www.affinity-law.com for more information about our firm, our people and our services.
We will be using this blog to provide what we hope will be valuable information and insights about various legal topics of interest. We will post information on a regular basis about specific legal topics, such as what to do if you’ve been sued, how to select a trademark, tips for business owners to avoid and address legal problems, and similar topics. We also will comment on legal topics and cases of interest that are in the news.
We want this blog to be an interactive experience so we encourage our visitors to comment on our posts. Please also like us on Facebook and follow us on Twitter.
Welcome again and thanks for visiting!